Categories
Opinions

How (And When) Not To Read A Book

I want to start this post with an apology: No, this is not a review, sorry if you expected otherwise. Instead, I want to share an opinion with you – and I hope to spark a few comments, because I’m really curious about YOUR thoughts on this.

As the title suggests, I want to talk about how to not read a book. Because let’s be honest: reading a book is very simple. Not reading it, on the other hand, can be a major strain on the psyche of any book lover, because in its wake comes the Abbreviation of Abandoning: the DNF pile. Oh, and how awful those three letters sound!

Awful, because we are avid readers, books are like the offspring of our mind, and DNFing a book feels like killing a kitten. Something horribly, right? Something we don’t want to do. Yes, we must not give in to our cravings of killing a book! (*Insert maniacal laughter here*)

Of course, there might be a good reason for you to abandon a book. Maybe the easiest one that comes to your mind is: because it’s crap.

You say this book is crap. But is it though?

I urge you to resist this temptation, and instead try to find out if this book is really crap, and for whom? All potential readers out there, or just You? And really for You (wholesome), or for the flavor of the moment of You?

Because You are not a constant. No one is, after all. The You that existed yesterday is not the same You that exists now, or will exist tomorrow. And no, I’m not talking about metaphysics, or in a spiritual sense, either. I’m just after the fact that we behave differently over the course of our life, a year, sometimes even over the course of a day or an hour! I think it’s called moods, and sometimes Your current world view will change with experiences.

That being said, I do have a rather small DNF pile. I’ve got a much larger HFY pile, though. And it is this idea – the HFY pile – that I want to introduce to you: Haven’t Finished Yet.

Because I’ve realized that the circumstances might change, and so will the way I experience a book. And I like to illustrate this with an example:

In the early days of my Kindle, back in 2011, I bought the whole Bigend cycle (I call it the Blue Ant Cycle) by William Gibson. It is his third three book cycle, after the Sprawl Cycle (the Neuromancer cycle) and the Bridge cycle (also known as the Futurematic cycle). I’ve enjoyed both of them, so clearly I expected a lot of the third cycle, starting with Pattern Recognition. So I dug into it – because, what could go wrong?

Clearly, the answer is everything, all at once. Until this day, I do not know why I clashed so hard against this book. There are several suspects, though:

  • It was my first time reading Gibson in his native language. I’ve read German translations of his first two novels.
  • Contrary to the first two cycles, this one is not cyberpunk (Sprawl) or post-cyberpunk (Bridge). In fact, Gibson moves back in time and technology; this book is more Speculative Science Fiction, and so it was very different from what I was expecting
  • I also had a different sense of the meaning of pattern recognition; I expected someone working with data, and that spoke to me because this was kind of my job back then. (And where was some data centered pattern recognition in the Bridge cycle.)

All in all, the story started out to be everything I didn’t expect it to be, and that led me to abandon it (I haven’t even touched the next two books).

But I’ve decided today to give it another go. Because my cyberpunk cravings can be fulfilled in another way, and I don’t hold the same expectations I did back then, and since this was easily a decade ago, most importantly I am not the same reader I was back then.

In other words: this book was pulled from my HFY pile, and if you have one of those, you don’t need to fret about stopping to read a book. Instead of killing it with the DNF, you can instead give in with gay abandon (in the other meaning of the word abandon) to put it in your HFY pile.

Feels good, doesn’t it?

Stefan's avatar

By Stefan

father of two, not enough time to read everything I want to read

6 replies on “How (And When) Not To Read A Book”

A well reasoned plea to fight to the bitter end. But once you’ve reached “a certain age” you begin to realize that there are so many great books out there to read still, and so few years to accomplish that goal! Life is too short to toss away your precious remaining reading hours on a book that does not meet your basic requirements. The last book I DNFed sounded like the author had rushed to meet a deadline or wasn’t as invested in her character as she had been with her other books. I put aside an engrossing book by Elizabeth Berg (one of my top ten favourite writers) to read the ebook that just popped up my TPL inbox. Since we ony have 21 days to read the book, I jumped right in, and was sorely disappointed. The sample chapters had been riveting. The balance of the story… left me feeling let down. Who knows, maybe when I like books that skim along the surface, I might go back to that one, but I sincerely doubt it! My Scorpio nature likes to dig deep! However, so much of what you say is true: we MUST give each book a fair chance before we DNF. A book should not be a life sentence: I remember you had to review a book that sucked up so much of your time, and seemed never-ending: I totally felt your pain! You rock, Stefan, in your dedication to do right by the authors you review: I hope they appreciate your dedication and loyalty!

Liked by 1 person

I appreciate your argument, buuuuut, it doesn’t completely work for me. Or, to put it another way, I think I have three piles.

Some books are crap. I might not go all the way out there to Sturgeon’s Law about 90% of everything being crap, but there are some that just are, admittedly IMHO. (I just finished one a couple of weeks ago because it was an assignment and I needed brain bleach when I finished writing it up.)

However, I think I have two of those other piles, because ‘Not For Me’ also feels like an important kind of judgment. The so many books, so little time conundrum is real, and if I hit something where the theme or the premise turns out to be one that turns me right off, I can recognize that it might be good of its type but it just isn’t my type.

And then there’s that pile you talk about, the HFY pile, for books I start that I’m not into NOW but recognize that I might pick back up again later, when either my mood shifts or circumstances change or I get a bit further away from the last book I read in that same vein or series and they’re just too close together.

Now I’ll go back to reading the holiday story I’m in the middle of, which demonstrates a classic case of HFY, because I dipped into some holiday stories when they came out in October and that was just too soon. Now that it’s AFTER the US Thanksgiving Day, it’s time for those to shine. Hopefully. We’ll see!

Liked by 1 person

Oh, yes, I think your third pile is a valid argument! There are lots of books that are certainly great for other people, but not for me.

The really crap pile is something I find hard to prove. For me, black leopard, red Wolf belongs to this category, yet I found people on Goodreads who are fiercely protecting this book.

I hope your HFY holiday book turns out to be good!

Like

Ironically, Black Leopard, Red Wolf went into that NFM pile for me. I didn’t think it was crap, but the way its narrative structure worked just didn’t work for me.

As I say frequently, YMMV, or specifically, Your Reading Mileage May Vary. Because it SO does!

Liked by 1 person

That is SO true! Also on the narrative structure for BLRW. I remember exactly when I DNFed the book – it was after the protagonist decided to take a break for a year. Because, yeah, that makes sense if you’re searching for a kidnapped child. (At least that was the impression the story gave me.)

Like

Leave a reply to Susan Cancel reply